She was the prettiest thing I'd seen
I'm in over my head or so it seemed
She turned to me, and smiled, how could this be
She's walking over, I start to freeze
All these other, but she comes to me
My hearts thumping so hard
Is this a dream

That's when I knew
This was too good to be true
When she walked up to another man next to me
I felt so dumb, because I made myself believe
She was the one for me
Why did I try

Then I, turned and walked away
Feeling so stupid
I just wanted to disappear
Then I, heard a voice say Hey
Could this be
Was she talking to me
Am I dreaming

That's when I knew
This was too good to be true
When she walked up to another man next to me
I felt so dumb, because I made myself believe
She was the one for me
Why did I try

Why did I try

That's when I knew
This was too good to be true
When she walked up to another man next to me
I felt so dumb, because I made myself believe
She was the one for me
Why did I try.
Correct  |  Mail  |  Print  |  Vote

That's When I Knew Lyrics

Josh Gaffney – That's When I Knew Lyrics

She was the prettiest thing I'd seen
I'm in over my head or so it seemed
She turned to me, and smiled, how could this be
She's walking over, I start to freeze
All these other, but she comes to me
My hearts thumping so hard
Is this a dream

That's when I knew
This was too good to be true
When she walked up to another man next to me
I felt so dumb, because I made myself believe
She was the one for me
Why did I try

Then I, turned and walked away
Feeling so stupid
I just wanted to disappear
Then I, heard a voice say Hey
Could this be
Was she talking to me
Am I dreaming

That's when I knew
This was too good to be true
When she walked up to another man next to me
I felt so dumb, because I made myself believe
She was the one for me
Why did I try

Why did I try

That's when I knew
This was too good to be true
When she walked up to another man next to me
I felt so dumb, because I made myself believe
She was the one for me
Why did I try.