She was the prettiest thing I'd seen
I'm in over my head or so it seemed
She turned to me, and smiled, how could this be
She's walking over, I start to freeze
All these other, but she comes to me
My hearts thumping so hard
Is this a dream

That's when I knew
This was too good to be true
When she walked up to another man next to me
I felt so dumb, because I made myself believe
She was the one for me
Why did I try

Then I, turned and walked away
Feeling so stupid
I just wanted to disappear
Then I, heard a voice say Hey
Could this be
Was she talking to me
Am I dreaming

That's when I knew
This was too good to be true
When she walked up to another man next to me
I felt so dumb, because I made myself believe
She was the one for me
Why did I try

Why did I try

That's when I knew
This was too good to be true
When she walked up to another man next to me
I felt so dumb, because I made myself believe
She was the one for me
Why did I try.
Correct  |  Mail  |  Print  |  Vote

That's When I Knew Lyrics